Brad Feld

Category: Investments

Yesterday was Return Path’s 10th Birthday.  Matt Blumberg, Return Path’s CEO and founder, wrote a great reflective post on his blog titled A Perfect Ten. Among other things he covers what he is proudest of from Return Path’s first decade as well as what he regrets or would have done differently.

Matt and his team have created a significant company that is profitable, a market leader in its segment, and is growing nicely.  It has a strong balance sheet and an excellent leadership team. While the business has evolved significantly from its creation a decade ago, it has always has a clear sense of purpose and vision which has stayed pretty steady, in large part due to Matt and his executive teams’ leadership and stability.

Since I’ve been involved in Return Path since 2000, I thought I’d tell my story of how I recall my initial involvement.  Some time in early 2000, we (Mobius) met with three entrepreneurs (Eric Kirby, George Bilbrey, and Kevin O’Connell) about an idea for a company they had created to provide “Internet Email Change of Address” services.  This was a process similar to what the US Post Office does when you physically move – where you fill out a change of address form – but for email when you change your email address.  The business was originally called IECOA but fortunately was changed to Veripost about the time we invested in it in 2000.

Veripost was physically based in the Mobius Colorado Incubator that we ran from 2000 to 2004.  Since it was one of the first companies in the incubator I got to know the founders and the early team well.  Veripost quickly grew to about 20 people, built a neat service, and started signing up partners.  They had one competitor – Return Path.  At first, Return Path was demonized, as in “those guys are giving away the service for free and are going to ruin the market” or “their technology sucks – they are just spending a lot more money than us to get visibility”.  While there were elements of this, it was more a function of a deep seated early rivalry than anything else.  Matt and Eric had met each other a few times and it turned out that Matt and George both knew each other from working together earlier in their careers at Mercer Management Consulting.  So, even though there was healthy competition, there was open contact and mutual respect.

When Veripost went out to raise their Series B financing, they met with a few investors that had recently met with Return Path, who was also out raising a round. I recall at least one of them giving feedback to the Veripost team that the two companies were identical in this very early market and rather than bludgeoning each other over the head, should consider joining forces.

Eric knew that I was good friends with Fred Wilson, one of Return Path’s investors through his fund Flatiron Partners (I was also a small investor in Flatiron Partners so indirectly a tiny investor in Return Path.)  Matt and Eric encouraged us to talk in the context of a merger and financing.  I can’t remember who initiated the call, but Fred and I had a typically frank conversation where we quickly cut to the chase and agreed that it was worth exploring merging the companies and doing a financing behind one company.

If I remember correctly, the call took less than 15 minutes.  It went something like this:

Brad: “This feels like a 50/50 deal – let’s just keep it simple.”

Fred: “I want a little more for my side because we’ve invested a lot more money than you have. How about 55/45.”

Brad: “Done.”

Matt and Eric had similarly effective conversations and agreed early on that there would be tough cuts on both sides with the goal of ending up with one company rather than two companies pretending to be one.  As part of that, they got comfortable with the idea of having two locations (NY for headquarters / sales; Colorado for engineering and ops).  Matt would be the CEO, the Veripost executives would transition out of the company with the Colorado engineering leadership becoming part of the management team.  The combined company would end up at 20 people which was the right size for the business.  Given that the Return Path brand was better known than the Veripost brand (and frankly was a better name) the combined company would be called Return Path.

Matt and Eric quickly built a joint plan and presented it to several of the VCs they had each been talking to.  Greg Sands at Sutter Hill totally got it, agreed with the thesis behind the merger, and put down a term sheet to lead a round of the merged company.  After some legal mechanics, the new Return Path was born to go after the ECOA market.  Eric, George, and Kevin transitioned out of Return Path as expected and the company began gaining ground quickly.

Simultaneously, George started a new company (with support from Eric) called Assurance Systems.  With it he tackled a new email related problem that he’d come up that he was calling “the email deliverability problem” – specifically that desired email was increasingly getting caught in spam filters, especially as more focus came on the “spam problem.”  Even though we (Mobius) hadn’t invested in Assurance Systems we gave George space in our incubator and stayed close to what he was doing, including plenty of “hey – how’s it going” moments in the bathroom.

Return Path helped out with the early sales and marketing and Assurance Systems was pretty quickly generating more revenue per month than the Return Path ECOA product.  It quickly became obvious that Assurance Systems should be part of Return Path and Matt and George worked out a deal for Return Path to acquire Assurance Systems.  Today, Assurance Systems is the core of Return Path (we sold off the ECOA business several years ago) and George and his co-founder Tom Bartel are still key members of the Return Path team.

I’ve got many other Return Path stories – many good, some bad – but most are instructive.  But I’ll let this one stand as a tribute to Return Path on its 10th anniversary.

Finally, in Matt’s post he thanks his investors and board members for our “unwavering support” over the years.  Matt – right back at you – thanks to you and everyone at Return Path for the incredible effort you have put in to building this great company.

Special Bonus Feature: Matt knows I Hate Powerpoint and I encourage you to read his post Powerpointless and Fred Wilson’s post Presentations vs Discussions.  Matt took a hint from my post The Best Board Meetings and ran the entire eight hour meeting without a single powerpoint slide.  It was awesome.


A month ago, NewsGator released TapLynx – their framework for building iPhone apps.  They took the core code of NetNewsWire for the iPhone, abstracted it out, and built a really powerful and easy iPhone app development system as an SDK.  A month later, the iPhone apps built on top of TapLynx are starting to appear, including All Things Digital, Variety, Discovery, TechStars, and the amazing and entertaining Foundry Group iPhone app.

You can download the TapLynx SDK for free to evaluate it.  You only pay if and when you deploy your app to production.  The license price for the TapLynx framework is $3,499 – when you consider the amount of code it includes and the time it’ll save you, it’s a steal.

That said, the folks at NewsGator have gotten into the holiday spirit.  For 24 hours, they are going to celebrate Black Friday (11/27) by offering 50 licenses for $500 each.  

A final note – the TechStars and Foundry Group iPhone apps were built by our friends at Slice of Lime.  They are one of the TapLynx Premium Partners and are ready to crank out an iPhone app for you whenever you are.


I’m in NY all week with a jam packed schedule so I thought it would be a good week to talk a little about how I use Gist since I’ll use it every day to help me deal with a shortened daily information routine.  As you probably know, we are investors in Gist and I’m on the board so – while this is fanboy stuff – there are also a few other goals of this post including (a) helping you understand the promise of Gist, (b) enticing you to give it a try, and (c) eliciting feedback from those of you that have given it a try and want more / better / different (e.g. feedback of any kind is good).

I’m going to start with the Dashboard View.  This is the one from yesterday (I grabbed a screen shot before I left for the airport) – I was intending to write this on the plane but my superpower kicked in and I slept most of the way.

gist

In the left hand column you can see the people that I have news on.  If you know my world, you’ll recognize a lot of those names.  They are the people that I have “at least some email contact with.”  If you squint, you can see that I’ve set “Importance” to at least 50 – I find this is the right threshold for me.  I then sort this column by “Name” as my brain likes alphabetical order instead of "most recent” order.  I set the time frame to “Last 48 hours” – that catches things if I don’t check at exactly the same time every day.  Finally, I turn off “tweets” in the dashboard as I find them too noisy.

I then work my way systematically down the list.  I start at the top, scan the center column to see if want to read anything on that person, click on any URL to expand, and then click the check mark to the right of the person’s name when done (to mark “as read” – at which point that person disappears from the dashboard view).  Gist automatically highlights the next name and I repeat.

I usually have between 25 and 50 names in the list – sometimes it gets as high as 100.  I find that this dashboard view gets almost all of the daily news I care about with regard to people I know.  It occasionally misses something – usually a person I care about that doesn’t fit about the “50 importance” threshold so I can quickly and easily change that.  But, for a first pass through what’s going on, this is a super efficient way to start the day.  Max time spent per day – 15 minutes (usually less).

It took me about two weeks of running Gist to get this Dashboard tuned just right.  Whenever someone would pop up that I didn’t care about, I’d click the universal sign for “no more of that” (the big red circle with the line through it – “Stop watching for new items”).  Once I got used to the tuning rhythm, it was trivial to deal with.

If you have Gist installed, give the Dashboard another try and give me feedback on what would make it easier to get up and running with it and using it every day.  If you don’t have Gist running, give it a try. 

Fanboy out – time for a run down Park Avenue – wave at me if you see me (no, not that Wave).


We’ve been investors in Oblong since 2007 and I’ve talked about them regularly on this blog including a post titled I’ve Seen The Future from my first meeting with them.  I’ve known two of the founders – John Underkoffler and Kevin Parent – since we lived together at MIT (we all lived in a fraternity called ADP on Mass Ave. at the same time, along with a bunch of other entrepreneurs including Colin Angle – the founder of iRobot and Jeet Singh / Joe Chung – the founders of ATG.)

A few months ago my partner Jason Mendelson was introduced to a reporter from Bloomberg who was looking for “innovative companies to interview” for an upcoming Bloomberg TV series called Bloomberg Innovators.  Jason immediately thought of Oblong and made the introduction. 

Bloomberg Innovators has four thirty minute episodes – the first one titled Turning Point is about Oblong.  In addition to highlighting the amazing stuff the gang at Oblong is doing, the show takes you through the history of how the innovation that is called Oblong’s g-speak Spatial Operating Environment was created.  As part of this, you get to see some pictures of John Underkoffler 20+ years ago in the Media Lab working on the Luminous Room along with some background on John’s work on the movie Minority Report.

If you are interested in how innovations evolve, the future of human computer interaction, Oblong, how some VCs think about investing in the future, or just want to have your mind blown with some amazing stuff, spend 30 minutes enjoying the show.

Bloomberg TV doesn’t allow embeds, so you’ll have to launch Bloomberg Innovators: Turning Point from here.


Bloomberg TV is running a show called Bloomberg Innovators.  One of our portfolio companies – Oblong – is the focus of the first episode that airs this Friday (10/30) on Bloomberg TV at 9pm and 11pm ET.  As a special bonus, Jason and my Donkey Kong machine are in the trailer and both Jason and Ryan are in the episode that stars John Underkoffler, Kwin Kramer, and a bunch of the Oblong gang.  Oh – and Jason’s hair looks funny.


The Gist iPhone app was released this morning.  It’s the first of two meaningful iPhone releases this week from companies I’m an investor in.  Not surprisingly the Gist iPhone app is tightly coupled with the overall Gist service which I’ve written about in the past. 

image

Bill French wrote a great review on iPhone CTO titled Mobile Professionals Develop Business Acuity and Information Readiness With New Gist iPhone AppIn this he clearly explains what Gist is trying to do, why it’s special-magic-happy, and where it has room for improvement.

Gist is providing a little Apple love today with a change to their avatar on Twitter.  If you are so inclined, give Gist a try and send me any feedback (good or bad) that you have.


A few weeks ago I wrote a post titled An Angel Investor Group Move That Makes Me VomitIn the post, I lambasted the practice of charging entrepreneurs to pitch to an angel group for funding.  I think this is completely backwards – the angel group members should cover all the costs and the entrepreneurs should not be charged.

Last week David Cohen (the founder of TechStars) wrote a post titled An offer to Funding Universe.  On 9/30, Funding Universe is having one of their CrowdPitch events in Denver.  The were originally charging $125 to present – David welcomed Funding Universe to Colorado and offered to pay the presentation fees for half the companies if Funding Universe covered the other half.

Funding Universe responded to David’s offer by having the Pitching Fee Removed!  Nice job guys.


For those of you that are regular readers, you know how excited I am about Gist, an investment we made earlier this year.  On Tuesday Gist launched their open beta program making Gist available to everyone.

The coverage of the launch was extensive with articles describing how Gist works and what it is useful for in sites including GigaOm, ReadWriteWeb, Forbes, Mashable, Cnet, eWeek, NetworkWorld, WebWorkerDaily, TechFlash, and Microsoft StartupZone.  Some of my favorite articles were FilltheFunnel (hint – iPhone screenshots) and MarketingProfessor (hint – what they like, what they don’t like – much of which is on the product roadmap.)

On a phone call with the Gist team last week, I reminded them that they only get to “open up to the world once”.  The company has been operating under a “closed beta” since we invested as they simultaneously built out the product functionality while insuring that their architecture scaled up to handle a huge amount of data (which it is already.) 

I’m super impressed by the Gist team – this is a gang that knows how to build and ship software.  At my first meeting, they put the date of 9/15/09 on the board for the launch of the service.  Over the last 60 days, they’ve been obsessed with performance, functionality, the first time user experience, and software quality.  I think they should be incredibly proud of what they’ve launched.

While this is still a very early step in the business, it’s an important one.  The Q4 roadmap is very full and – if the last six months is an indicator – will be filled with many steady releases of new functionality to the service. 

I use Gist every day and have found it to be immensely helpful when tightly integrated into my work and information flow.  I encourage all of you to give it a try and give me as much feedback as you are willing to give as we try to extend it to be useful to all business professionals.


My friends at Rally Software continue to grow like crazy.  As the Agile software development methodologies goes mainstream, Rally continues to lead the market in providing Agile application lifecycle management (ALM) software.

One of the things Rally has been doing as part of “bringing Agile to the masses” is the Rally Agile Success Tour.  As a recent attendee at one of the events said:

"I thought this would be a Rally sales pitch… It was most definitely not that."

If you are an Agile practitioner or interested in learning more about Agile, the Rally Agile Success Tour has stops in Boston on 9/17, Seattle on 10/1, Chicago on 10/15, and London on 10/29.  The cool thing is that rather than hearing a sales pitch, you’ll hear real customer stories from the likes of AOL, Constant Contact, Sermo, BMC, Microsoft, Boeing, and Getty Images.

When I invested in Rally in 2003, I was betting on the notion that Agile would go mainstream within a reasonable period of time.  It has and I’m super proud of the company the Rally gang has created.